The Fall Smart-Casual Look
There's a two-to-four week window every autumn where the weather is genuinely unresolved: too cool for a single shirt, too mild to justify a real coat. Most men either overdress or underdress it. This guide is for getting it right. Every pick here was chosen to work in that specific temperature band, layered or not, without looking like you planned it too hard.
The Knitwear
The why behind each pick, how to choose between them, and what to look for is free with an account.
The Arlo Sweater Polo in Oat Texture Knit
The Taylor Stitch Arlo Sweater Polo is a $148 cotton-alpaca knit that lands solidly in the space between a polo shirt and a crewneck, with construction that's honest for the price if not exceptional.
Taylor Stitch's Valencia Sweater Polo is a 7-gauge cotton-linen knit with a Milano rib placket that holds its shape, made in China, $148, and worth a look if you can catch it through the Workshop pre-order at $120.
Madewell's Tipped Knit Button-Up is a $118 slub cotton shirt that layers well, runs large, and asks nothing of you, including admiration for how it's made.
The Shirts
Whiting - Blue And Ecru Oran Check Overshirt
Wax London's Whiting overshirt in a French-woven oran check is $235, true to size, and bold enough that the pattern is doing most of the work — which, at this construction level, it earns the right to do.
Drake's x Mayumi Yoshida rugby shirt: 9.4oz yarn-dyed cotton jersey, made in Portugal, rubber buttons, embroidered back motif, $345, and a louder stripe than Drake's usually ships.
Taylor Stitch's Short Sleeve California in a 7.5-oz. cotton-hemp-wool double knit: true to size, $128, and one of the few short-sleeve shirts at this price where the collar still lies flat after a dozen washes.
rag & bone's Jack Infuse Denim Shirt uses a 60/40 cotton-lyocell blend to make a denim shirt that drapes more like a casual shirt than workwear; at $268, the construction holds up, but it runs small, wrinkles in transit, and is better tried in store than ordered blind.
Taylor Stitch's Conrad Shirt in Heather Chili Pincord: 4.5 oz. organic cotton, double-needle felled seams, $128, and one of the more honestly priced camp-collar shirts at this construction level.
The Outer Layer
Indigo Stripe Denim Field Jacket
Drake's $895 indigo-stripe field jacket uses 14.2oz Japanese denim, eight pockets, and a corduroy collar to make the case that a denim jacket can be outerwear rather than casualwear, provided you're comfortable with the stripe doing most of the talking.
Why each piece made the shortlist, how to choose between them, and what to look for. Create a free account to read it all and tune the picks to your taste.
Create a free account →